The number worth comparing instead
Once GPD is understood as a bench-tested ceiling rather than a promise, comparing two systems by that number alone stops being very useful unless you also know they were tested under the same protocol — which, per the NSF/ANSI 58 bench parameters above, most are. What actually predicts your day-to-day experience is a mix of things a spec sheet states, plus one thing only your house can answer.
The closest thing to a "real" number is your own feed pressure and temperature, measured at the point the system connects. A $15 screw-on pressure gauge and a kitchen thermometer answer a question a GPD label can't: how far below bench conditions does your house actually run? That answer, not the number on the box, decides whether a 600 GPD system will feel like 600 GPD or considerably less.
Where GPD compares poorly across brands, the drain-to-product ratio compares honestly, because it's a plain statement of how much of the water entering the system becomes usable output versus how much goes down the drain — our guide to the RO waste water ratio goes through why older systems run 3:1 or 4:1 against you while modern tankless designs are commonly 2:1 or better. Two systems can carry an identical 600 GPD rating and differ meaningfully in how much water each one wastes to hit it.
A verified NSF/ANSI 58 certification is worth more than an uncertified GPD figure, too, because it's independently tested contaminant and TDS reduction performance rather than a peak-output number a manufacturer self-reports. Between two systems, the one with third-party verification behind its numbers — GPD included — is the safer bet even if its printed rating is lower. And if you're choosing a tank system rather than tankless, tank size becomes the figure that predicts burst behavior at the sink more directly than GPD does, since it's the buffer you're actually drawing from between refills.
None of this makes GPD worthless. It correctly separates a 75 GPD tank tier built for light drinking-water use from the 600-to-800 GPD tankless tier built for busier households and rougher conditions — it's the right number for choosing a class. It's the wrong number for predicting a specific kitchen, and the figures above — your own pressure, your own temperature, the drain ratio, and the certification — are what actually do that job.